How do you know if an eyeliner REALLY lasts all day? If it lasts through the blood, sweat, and tears of a 30 cardio workout + an hour of strength training and yoga. I did a little experiment on the Urban Decan 24/7 glide on eye pencil in Zero. To be honest, I'm so afraid of wearing pencil liner and makeup in general to sweat-prone places, because I'm afraid it will smudge, slip, and give me some nice and weird streaks all over my face. Brilliant.
My workout/game face. I'm slightly insecure about my naked face so I opted for a little lip balm and foundation (Marcelle Hydra-C) which I guess was also a good way to test it's staying power as well. I pretty much skipped everything else: mascara, bronzer... lalalala
Before... I used a little Urban Decay 24/7 Glide On Eye Pencil. This is a HUGE cult product. I tried to set it with some Rimmel Stay Matte Powder, but I'm slightly disappointed that it transferred onto my "crease area" before I even started to work out. I don't know if you can tell... but there's a slight black line on my lid.
After...The eyeliner wore off in the slightest bit. It smudged on my lid (some more), but for the most part stayed put. The funny thing is... my whole face of foundation stayed on. I guess the Marcell foundation is stay all day type stuff.
Now on to the ramble-y part... about exercise. It's not exactly my favourite topic but I thought I should share.
I had an epiphany. Exercising. It's never been my strong point or the first thing on my mind. I haven't exercised in about 2 years. Two years ago I did Tae Kwon Do religiously. Three days a week. But now... nothing. Bad I know. Shame on me. I'm good at making excuses for myself. On weekdays, I leave at 7:30am for work and get back home at nearly 8pm. I set out my weekends for some nice rest and relaxation. So I never try to make time for exercise.
The best part? My mom is a fitness instructor in her spare time. She teaches both a yoga/pilates and martial arts class. She's always telling me to work out more ... like a rebellious child, I never listen. Two years ago, I started university away from home. I ate nasty, unhealthy cafeteria food. The most exercise I did was walk to class. Now I'm back home for a 4 month work term and everyone in my family works out at least 2x a week.
My epiphany? Coming home from an All-You-Can-Eat Sushi date. For pretty petite people (Me at 4'11'' and my boyfriend at 5'4''), we can gobble down at least 35 pieces of sushi/sashimi each plus all the cooked items like dumplings, tempura, etc AND dessert. The picture above is HALF the meal. We had so much food we had to put some plates on the table beside us. We often overestimate ourselves and order a little too much... it happens all the time. This particular time we ended up struggling to get home from home. Literally limping in agony to get to the subway.
It has nothing to do with how much I weigh or look, and everything to do with how I feel.
I hate feeling fatigued and tired from walking a couple blocks. I know it's not healthy to not exercise and I've been quite ignorant. So I finally started working out... after 2 years. I'm doing Jillian Michaels (of the Biggest Loser) 30 day shred, along with going to my Mom's weekend yoga class. Lemme tell you... the first workout I did last week... felt like the longest 30 minutes of my life. I've also been running home from the bus stop... despite looking crazy with a backpack and heeled ankle booties.
Any ways, I'm going to try to stick to a schedule of working out at least 2 times a week.
Conclusion: I need to work out more. and Urban Decay's eyeliner is pretty good but it does smudge. and is certainly not 24 hours if you're going to the gym.
What's your longest lasting eyeliner? Do you work out often? If so, do you wear makeup to the gym? Let me know if you have any suggestions for good cardio work outs. :)

I agree with you on the eyeliner! I love it, but it doesn't last all day for me. It lasts pretty well on my upper lash line but by the end of the day it can no longer be seen on my water line. That's great that you've started exercising regularly! It does make you feel so much better because when I go a long time without exercising I feel so sluggish!
ReplyDeleteIt's not half bad, but not HG material :P I really need to work out more.. still... :P
DeleteI'm actually in the market for a new eyeliner because nothing (I've tried till now) and I repeat nothing lasts on my waterline, it's kind of sad really :(
ReplyDeleteI don't wear liner on my waterline... it just avoids the problem all together!
DeleteI have no workout suggestions because I'm as lazy and unmotivated as they come. I'm the type of person that will workout two months out of the year just before summer ;) I was doing a really simple cardio workout last summer that was the prequel to px90. Pretty simple stuff, but it killed me! lol
ReplyDeleteI'll have to check out the Marcelle foundation. I'm amazed that it lasted through your workout! :)
P90X you mean? LOL ... I'm incredibly lazy myself :P
DeleteI didn't have much luck with the UD eyeliner. It smudges onto my lower lashes very quickly. But it doesn't look too bad. Just a bit of smudging.
ReplyDeleteYour mom sounds really fit!
I always find excuses for myself too, but I think I'm worse since my schedule is no where as long as yours is :X
Yeah! Kind of hyped up... I work a lot... but I KNOW I have time... I just need to make it... :)
DeleteI find gel eyeliners typically last longer. Try Bobbi Brown. Another favorite of mine is Physicians Formula lash booster eyeliner. They both stay put all day for me when I apply eye primer.
ReplyDeleteI used to be so disciplined in my exercise routine but I have gotten really unmotivated. More excuses not to go than to go. I find when I buy a gym membership, it would force myself to go more to get my $ worth haha!
I've had bad luck with gel liners but I do LOVE Lash booster! I would totally buy a gym membership.. The only issue is that I get in for free!
DeleteI also wear makeup to the gym but find it so hard to fit in time in my work week. I am looking forward to spring though so I can be out walking and running.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad to know I'm not the only one :) ... Spring and sunshine will be nice... hopefully i can stay motivated by then (:
DeleteI still have never tried these eyeliners but I rarely wear pencil liners. I hate the gym lol. I'm slim but could definately afford to tone up. When it's warmer I just like walking everywhere for my exercise.
ReplyDeleteI feel the same way about exercise. I'm tiny but I'd like to be strong and tiny :P
DeleteI do walk quite a bit...so I guess that counts. I think I'm starting to move away from pencil and closer to liquids. :)
I like using the Urban Decay liners if I plan to smudge them and smoke out my eyes, but I have the same problem as you with that "crease line" otherwise. So, great product for a specific use, but it's not a 24hr product IMO!
ReplyDeleteI'm really active for work so I don't hit the gym, but I like dance, yoga, and hiking as hobbies so I guess that helps. It sucks when you're working long hours though!
Steph you are beautiful!
ReplyDeleteI wish I could eat that much food and look as good as you, lol.......
Jac x0x
matillysthisnthat.blogspot.com.au
I don't have a long lasting eyeliner. That is actually what I am trying to find!
ReplyDeleteI am in the same boat as you! I used to work out pretty religiously as well, but then stopped. Now I have gained a few extra pounds and don't really have my "shape" that I used to be. So I need to make time to work out.
Give us an update on how it goes =)
I have a huge problem with pencil eye liners smudging on me, so I recently converted to gel liner, and safe to say I'm not looking back anytime soon!
ReplyDeleteAll you can eat sushi places are so funny to me. Every time I plan on going, I get super excited, but once I'm finished eating I always feel like I'm going to explode from overeating.
Sue
My longest lasting eyeliner is MAC's Blacktrack. I talked about it on my blog, but it really is as great as everyone says! I think you should try it out because UD's Zero smudges on me after a while. I don't wear ANY makeup to the gym, but I haven't gone in a long time hahaha.
ReplyDeleteJust added the Followers widget :)
ReplyDeleteSue
Thanks so much for linking up to my weekend Beauty Bloggers Blog Hop! Hope to see you there next weekend too <3
ReplyDeleteJessi in Wonderland
I always have that problem too where eyeliner goes into my crease! So so annoying! UD liners usually stay in place, except maybe a slight smudge into my crease at the end of the day. As for working out, I always go through phases where I'm really good for a while, then I'm REALLY bad! Lol. I'm trying to be better about it by going running more often! It's so hard to stay motivated! My parents are hard core about working out so they always help me by bugging me to death!
ReplyDeleteI haven't tried the UD eyeliner. I always use gel eyeliner. I like the ones from Bobbie Brown.
ReplyDeleteI have a problem sticking to my workout schedule. I try to work out 2-3 times a week but it's hard to stay motivated.
The Eyeko skinny eyeliner stays for a long time and it doesn't smudge. I went to the pool wearing it. Then when I took a shower, I washed my face and I totally forgot I had eyeliner. But it stayed without any problem.
ReplyDeleteI never EVER wear make up when I work out. At first I used to put some eyeliner but it ended up almost all over my then so now I just use a bit of lipbalm.
ReplyDeleteMaria (=
craftyowl93.blogspot.com
I never work out and if I do I never bother wearing makeup cause I can imagine it to glide off my face! x
ReplyDeletewww.justshazea.blogspot.com
I dont like to wear makeup to the gym. I wash my face before workout to keep my face clean so that pores could exclude all the dirt. I usually only wear an eye pencil or kajal. :)
ReplyDeleteSarah
PrettyGloss - makeup, beauty & a lil gibberish
Haha, very humorously written post. :) I was actually just thinking this morning that I don't think I will go back to pencil eye liners because I recently purchased a stila liquid eyeliner (in grey) that I am *really* loving. Good luck with your work outs!
ReplyDeleteI rarely work for my eyes , commonly kohl is enough. I never applied eyeliner properly -_- pity on me. Woo you are working for fitness. I've done Tae Kwon Do in my grade 8 , that thing hurt my legs pretty much!
ReplyDeleteAree With Umbrella
Goodness gracious, now how the heck do you eat that much food?! I'll fall into a comatose state lol! I don't like the eye pencil that much, for me it doesn't stay on "24/7" and it kind've just smears as the day goes on. Bobbi Brown gel liner, now that ishh stays on really well!! :)
ReplyDeleteI really want to try this urban decay pencil - I guess sort of lasting is pretty good for a gym session x
ReplyDeletelamourjosie.com
Rimmel's products are nice when it comes to long lasting . But I hardly use mascara ( AH people would never leave anyone with big eyes) .
ReplyDeleteYumm , you've a lot of sushi . I'm jealous .
Noor @ Noor's Place
You look so lovely dear! :))
ReplyDeleteXO,
http://www.rosychicc.com
I wear makeup to the gym but it varies depending on when I'm going. If it's after work then I'm wearing my full face from the day but if it's a weekend, I'll just slap on some BB cream and mascara. Like you I didn't exercise for the longest time but now I work out regularly. I have a personal trainer that I work with twice a week doing CrossFit and I also take Zumba/yoga classes. You should try Zumba - it's so much fun!
ReplyDeletexo, alison*elle
I use that same mascara but in Perversion (their darkest black) and love it! I set it with Lancome black eyeshadow powder and it stays for me all day, even at the gym where I sweat like a dog. I know, gross!
ReplyDeleteAs far as working out, I never knew what working out was... Yup I was a big couch potato! That was until 1.5 years ago when my bf started pushing me to go and now I actually like it (most days lol). So keep on trying dear! ;)
andrea
anakalui
I wish my mom was a fitness instructor! I wish I could get back into working out as well. We're lucky that our Asian metabolism is on our side, but I do want to be healthier too.
ReplyDeleteAnd as much as I love the 24/7 liner, it definitely does not last 24 hours. Four or five hours is it for me and that's with primer.
Good luck with getting back into the swing of exercising!
i cant believe we weren't following you before! i swear i clicked follow ages ago! but woo 700th follower! thanks for always commenting on our blog <3
ReplyDeletebut anyway that urban decay eyeliner sounds good! considering it didnt budge alot after working out; pencil eyeliners always smudge and flake on me so i dont even own any atm haha
goodluck on being healthy! im sort of trying to be healthy as well xx